Landlord services compared

Landlord services in South Yorkshire, compared

Paying 16.8% a month and paying nothing can both be sensible, depending on your town and how much of the tenancy you want to run yourself.

Disclosure: This site is published by Loud Crowd IT Ltd, which provides marketing services to Kerrigans Property. Kerrigans is one of the eight entries below, listed in its alphabetical place, and the link to it is marked as sponsored.

Key facts

Options compared
8, listed A to Z
Towns
Barnsley, Doncaster, Rotherham, Sheffield
Free council routes
Rotherham, Sheffield
Guaranteed rent
Barnsley lease, Sheffield scheme
Last checked
2 Nov 2026

Quick answer

For a steady monthly figure, look at Barnsley's leasing route or Sheffield's rent guarantee. To run the tenancy yourself, Rotherham's free tenant finder or an online service costs the least. To hand everything over, compare St Leger Lettings, MakeUrMove and the local agents in your town on their written fee sheets.

The options side by side

Prices are as published on 2 Nov 2026. Every figure traces to the source linked in that entry further down.

OptionRouteAreaPublished priceWhat stays with you
Barnsley Council leasing routeGuaranteed rent leaseBarnsleyNo fee published. Rent is agreed with the provider and likely to sit slightly below local housing allowanceLittle day to day. You agree with the provider who deals with repairs
Kerrigans PropertyLocal letting agent, three packagesDoncasterLet only 132% of a month's rent, £800 minimum. Managed levels 12% or 15% a month after a 90% set-up fee (all inc. VAT)The tenancy on Bronze, repairs on Silver, little on Gold
MakeUrMoveOnline tenant find, optional managementOnline£150 one-off advert. £99 a year membership, or 10% inc. VAT a month fully managedEverything after the let on membership, little on fully managed
OpenRentOnline tenant findUK-wide onlineFree on OpenRent, £29 on portals, £58 with tenancy set-up (all inc. VAT). References £30 eachViewings, then the tenancy unless you add its extras
Rotherham Council tenant finderFree council tenant finderRotherhamFreeThe whole tenancy
Sheffield Private Rented SolutionsFree council scheme with rent guaranteeSheffieldFree to join, with no tenant introduction feesManagement of the home and the tenancy
St Leger LettingsCouncil-owned company, full managementDoncaster12% of rent charged, plus £100 + VAT tenant finder and £50 + VAT set-up. Tenant find alone is £250 + VATVery little on full management
Your Move BarnsleyHigh street agent, three service levelsBarnsleyTenant find from £720 inc. VAT. Managed levels 14.4% or 16.8% inc. VAT a month, plus set-up from £474The tenancy on LetBasic, less on LetEssentials, little on LetComplete

What a year costs at £750 a month

Percentages hide the real bill, so here is one home run through each published price: £750 a month for 12 months, which is £9,000 of rent. We picked £750 as a round figure to show the sums. It isn't a local average. Repairs, certificates and optional extras are left out, and these services don't do the same amount of work, so the cheapest line isn't automatically the best deal. Our guide to letting agent fees covers the extras to ask about. Weighing full management against tenant find? Full Property Management, another landlord site we run, compares full management and tenant find side by side.

OptionThe sumYear one
Rotherham Council tenant finderNo charge£0
Sheffield Private Rented SolutionsNo charge£0
OpenRent with tenancy set-up£58 + one £30 reference£88
MakeUrMove advert only£150 one-off£150
St Leger Lettings tenant find only£250 + VAT£300
Your Move LetBasicMinimum fee£720
Kerrigans Bronze, let only132% of £750£990
MakeUrMove fully managed£150 + 10% of £9,000£1,050
St Leger Lettings full management£180 inc. VAT in fees + 12% of £9,000£1,260
Kerrigans Silver, rent collection90% of £750 + 12% of £9,000£1,755
Kerrigans Gold, full management90% of £750 + 15% of £9,000£2,025
Your Move LetComplete£474 + £120 deposit registration + 16.8% of £9,000£2,106

Our arithmetic, using prices inc. VAT where published. St Leger's 12% is taken as written, because its page doesn't say whether VAT applies. Barnsley's lease isn't shown because the rent is agreed case by case. Inventory charges vary by provider and are left out of every line.

The eight options, A to Z

1 of 8 · Guaranteed rent lease · Barnsley

Barnsley Council leasing route

The council works with registered housing providers who lease homes from private landlords. For the length of the lease the provider pays you an agreed monthly rent, and that rent carries on when the home is empty.

Who it suits
A Barnsley landlord who cares more about a steady monthly figure than the top rent the street could fetch.
What to watch for
You give up some rent for the certainty, and the home has to pass the council's inspection against its minimum standards first.
  • You agree the lease length with the provider
  • The provider can cover tenant sign-up, rent collection, inspections and gas and electric tests
  • Prefer to keep managing? The Housing Options Team can help you find a tenant instead

Source: Barnsley Council: help to let and manage your rental property. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

2 of 8 · Local letting agent, three packages · Doncaster

Kerrigans Property

Disclosure: This site is published by Loud Crowd IT Ltd, which provides marketing services to Kerrigans Property.

A Doncaster agent with three packages: Bronze lets the home and hands it over, Silver adds rent collection and Gold adds full management. Marketing, accompanied viewings, referencing and arranging the safety certificates sit in all three, and the fee table is on its landlord page.

Who it suits
A Doncaster landlord who wants an agent based in the town and would rather have inspections and legal letters inside the percentage on a managed package.
What to watch for
The monthly fee is charged on rent collected, but managing an empty property between tenancies is 3% on Gold and Silver. A written inventory is £120, and withdrawing from management costs the full fee in the first 12 months, then 75% of a month's rent.
  • Gold and Silver include a rental warranty for the first six months. Renewing it is 3.6% of the annual rent
  • On Gold and Silver the monthly percentage falls once rent reaches £1,500
  • Propertymark member, in The Property Ombudsman. Kerrigans Property Ltd, company 09526153, 23 Windsor Road, Doncaster DN2 5BS. Call 01302 769276

Source: Kerrigans Property: landlord information. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

3 of 8 · Online tenant find, optional management · Online

MakeUrMove

One advertising package lists your home on Rightmove, Zoopla and Primelocation, and offers and tenancy agreements are handled in its portal. After that you pick self-management with a membership or hand the tenancy over.

Who it suits
A landlord who wants portal adverts at a fixed price and may want to hand over management later without changing company.
What to watch for
Membership covers up to five properties and is subject to application. Ask whether your postcode has a property manager before you pick fully managed, because the pricing page doesn't say.
  • Membership includes compliance reminders and certificate storage
  • Fully managed includes a named property manager, arrears handling and routine inspections
  • Out-of-hours emergency cover is optional

Source: MakeUrMove pricing. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

4 of 8 · Online tenant find · UK-wide online

OpenRent

The lowest published prices among the paid options here, as long as you can show people round. Its £58 package adds tenant applications, an online contract, deposit registration and first-month rent collection.

Who it suits
A landlord nearby with time for viewings who is happy to run the tenancy.
What to watch for
The viewings are yours, or from £49 through its accompanied service. The pricing page also shows a £70 Rightmove upgrade as an optional extra, so ask which portals your package includes.
  • Monthly rent collection is £10
  • Management Plus is £19 a month: emergency cover for up to three fixes a year
  • Rent guarantee insurance is £299 for 12 months, after successful OpenRent referencing

Source: OpenRent pricing. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

5 of 8 · Free council tenant finder · Rotherham

Rotherham Council tenant finder

The council matches your home with people looking for private rented housing across the borough and advertises it for you. You stay in control of who moves in and can keep advertising elsewhere.

Who it suits
A Rotherham landlord who is happy to self-manage and would welcome help with the first month's costs.
What to watch for
This finds a tenant and stops there. Its page doesn't offer a rent guarantee, so don't budget as though it does. Tenancy support depends on the tenant's circumstances.
  • Current incentives include rent in advance and a tenancy deposit paid
  • A local housing allowance top-up is also listed
  • A free housing health and safety assessment and a landlord liaison officer come with it

Source: Rotherham Council: private sector lettings support. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

6 of 8 · Free council scheme with rent guarantee · Sheffield

Sheffield Private Rented Solutions

Sheffield City Council matches your home to people on its waiting list, runs the viewings and handles the contract. Its page lists a rent guarantee, cover for tenant damage and a bond worth a month's rent.

Who it suits
A Sheffield landlord who will manage the home but wants a safety net on rent and damage for no fee.
What to watch for
The page ties the guarantee to the fixed term of the tenancy, and the Renters' Rights Act has removed fixed-term assured tenancies. Ask the team on 0114 205 3112 how long the guarantee runs today. The council can't manage the tenancy for you.
  • Your account manager visits in months 1, 6 and 12
  • You make the final decision on any tenancy
  • A managing agent, if you use one, must be accredited by the Responsible Landlords Scheme

Source: Sheffield City Council: help with renting your property. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

7 of 8 · Council-owned company, full management · Doncaster

St Leger Lettings

St Leger Homes is the City of Doncaster Council's housing company, and St Leger Lettings is the arm that manages homes for private landlords. Rent accounts, repairs, inspections and antisocial behaviour all sit with its team.

Who it suits
A Doncaster landlord who wants published prices and full management from a housing specialist.
What to watch for
The 12% has no VAT note on the page while the other fees do, so get the VAT position in writing. It covers Doncaster only.
  • A multi-property discount is available
  • Gas safety check £46.76 + VAT, electrical safety check £150 + VAT, EPC £110 + VAT
  • Packages can be tailored if you want to keep some tasks. Call 01302 862271

Source: St Leger Lettings: our offer for landlords. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

8 of 8 · High street agent, three service levels · Barnsley

Your Move Barnsley

Three levels, from finding and referencing a tenant to full management with a routine visit at least every six months. Its Barnsley page links a May 2026 fee sheet, and the figures here come from that sheet.

Who it suits
A Barnsley landlord who wants a branch to deal with and may move up or down a level between tenancies.
What to watch for
Read the extras. Deposit registration is £120, arranging works is 12% inc. VAT, and serving notice to end the instruction within 24 months of a tenancy can cost up to two months' rent inc. VAT.
  • LetBasic is one month's rent + VAT, with a £600 + VAT minimum
  • Set-up is 50% of a month's rent once rent reaches £1,000 a month
  • Client money protection through Propertymark, and The Property Ombudsman logo on the fee sheet

Source: Your Move Barnsley landlord services and fee sheet. Checked 2 Nov 2026.

Before you sign anything

Fixed-term assured tenancies have gone under the Renters' Rights Act, so any scheme or contract written around a fixed term deserves a direct question about how it works now. Our guide to how guaranteed rent works in South Yorkshire explains the lease and guarantee models. A lease to a housing provider may need your lender's or insurer's agreement, so start with Consent to Let if the home is mortgaged. Whichever route you take, the safety paperwork stays your job to get right: our landlord certificates guide lists it.

How we chose

An option made this list if it met all four of these tests, which you can check yourself:

  1. It takes private landlords with a home in at least one South Yorkshire town.
  2. Its own website or council page sets out what it does for landlords.
  3. Together, the entries cover a different way of letting: lease, council scheme, online, agent.
  4. We could trace each figure we quote to its published source.

It is a short list of routes and doesn't include every agent in the county. We haven't used these services ourselves, and nothing here is scored or rated. The order is A to Z, so a position on the page says nothing about quality. Local trades sit in Local Help, and each town has its own guide: Barnsley, Doncaster, Rotherham and Sheffield.

Questions landlords ask

What landlord services can I get in Barnsley?

On this list, three local routes: the council's leasing route through a registered housing provider, help finding a tenant from its Housing Options Team, and Your Move Barnsley on the high street. Online services such as OpenRent and MakeUrMove are another option, so check your postcode with them first.

Is guaranteed rent available in Barnsley?

Yes, through a lease with a registered housing provider. Barnsley Council's page says you get an agreed monthly rent for the term, including when the home is empty, and that it is likely to be slightly below local housing allowance rates.

Is guaranteed rent the same as rent guarantee insurance?

No. With a lease, a provider commits to pay you a set rent. Insurance pays out on a claim when your tenant doesn't pay, usually with referencing conditions: OpenRent's policy needs successful OpenRent referencing.

Do South Yorkshire councils charge landlords for these schemes?

Rotherham and Sheffield both say theirs are free. Barnsley's leasing page publishes no fee, and the provider's management cost feeds into your rent. St Leger Lettings in Doncaster does charge, because it is a paid management service.

Can I self-manage in Doncaster and still get help?

Yes. The City of Doncaster Council's Private Landlord Liaison Service is a single point of contact for private landlords, with guidance on legal duties and tenancy management and one-to-one appointments you can request by email.

Can I start with one of these and change later?

Usually, but check your contract first, because notice terms and exit fees differ. Our guide to changing letting agent walks through the handover.

Where to go next